top of page
St James Outside 07.jpg

Reflection on the readings for the 8th November, Remembrance Sunday

Nov 9
6 min read



Readings: ; Matthew 25:1-13

 

Today’s reflection is by the Vicar, the Revd Canon Jonathan Cain.

 

Poppy Fields

 

There is a field in northern Belgium where the poppies still grow.

 

In spring, the red flowers move in the breeze like waves on water.  Visitors walk quietly between rows of white headstones.  Schoolchildren trace names carved into stone.  Families search for surnames that belong to them.  The place is peaceful now, almost impossibly peaceful.

 

It was not always so.

 

Just over a hundred years ago the same ground was a landscape of mud, shell-craters and shattered trees.  The air carried the smell of wet earth, smoke and decay.  Men lived for weeks at a time in trenches where sleep was scarce, conditions were appalling and death was a constant companion.

 

Imagine a young soldier standing there before dawn.

 

His boots are soaked through.  His shoulders ache beneath the weight of his equipment.  Somewhere back home there are people who love him and long for his return.  He has not slept properly for days.  He is afraid, though he tries not to show it.  He does not know whether he will still be alive by nightfall.

 

Then comes the order to move.

The stories we tell about war often focus on generals, politicians and great battles, but the reality is that most soldiers are not thinking about history.  They are thinking about the next few minutes.  They are thinking about the friend beside them, about duty, responsibility and survival.

I recently heard the story of Fr William Doyle who was an Army Chaplain in the First World War.  During the big battles of that conflict, Fr William went into no-man’s-land many times to help wounded soldiers back to the relative safety of the trenches.  He died at Passchendaele in 1917.  In recent times letters have been sent to Pope Leo with a request that Fr William be recognised as a Martyr of Charity and made a Saint.  His story, and others like it is compelling not because it celebrates war, but because it captures something true about it.  Again and again, ordinary people find themselves surrendering their own safety for the sake of others.  They place themselves in danger so that somebody else might live.

 

That is what we gather to remember today.

 

Not the triumph of one nation over another.  Not military victories or defeats.  We gather to honour those who gave up their right to protect themselves in order to protect others.

 

Standing among the poppies of Flanders, one question inevitably arises.  Was the sacrifice in vain?

 

It is a difficult question because history refuses easy answers.  The First World War was followed by the Second.  The world was not cured of violence.  In the Festival of Remembrance broadcast from the Royal Albert Hall last night British service personnel from more recent conflicts in Bosnia, Iraq and Afghanistan were recognised.  Even now, while we gather here in peace, others are living through the realities of conflict as each generation inherits both the gifts and the unfinished business of those who came before it.

 

The question is not whether the world became perfect as a result of the sacrifice of the soldiers of Flanders and other conflicts.  Plainly it did not.

 

The deeper question is whether their sacrifice still speaks.

 

A few weeks ago I had coffee with a former soldier who completed two tours of Afghanistan.  For most of us that conflict has faded into history.  For him it has not.

He witnessed things that will never leave him.  He lost comrades during his service and others afterwards through addiction and suicide.  He lives with PTSD.  His marriage ended.  His civilian career collapsed.  Eventually he chose to give up a settled home and live a largely transient existence, tramping from place to place, living out of doors, because it was the only way he could find to cope with memories that continue to haunt him.

 

As I listened to him, it struck me that the sacrifice did not end when the fighting stopped.  The sacrifice goes on.

 

When we gather on Remembrance Sunday, we rightly remember the dead.  But we also remember those who continue to carry the consequences of war in their minds, bodies and hearts.  Some wounds remain visible and many do not.  Some burdens are carried with remarkable dignity while others are carried in silence.

 

That is why remembrance must always be more than nostalgia.  It is an act of attention, an acknowledgement of cost and a refusal to look away.

 

This week Peter Taylor, a British Army veteran in our congregation, shared a poem he has written for Remembrance Sunday which we have reproduced in the notice sheet this week.  Reflecting on those distant battlefields, he writes:

"There are poppies growing in some distant field;There are brave souls below who would not yield."

 

Later he describes them as:

"Ordinary people, great courage they showed,A great debt of sadness is owed."

 

I find that phrase particularly moving: ordinary people.  Not mythical heroes.  Not figures carved out of legend.  Ordinary people.  People who laughed and worried.  People who fell in love, raised families and made plans for the future.  People whose lives were interrupted by events beyond their control.  People who found themselves in extraordinary circumstances and were asked to bear extraordinary burdens.

 

If we are to honour them properly, we should resist any temptation to romanticise war because the reality of war is too terrible for that.  War forces people to take sides.  It demands certainty at moments when nuance often becomes impossible.  Afterwards, in the relative safety of peace, we can begin again to ask difficult questions and explore complexity.  We should do that.  But we should never do so in a way that diminishes the memory or sacrifice of those who were called upon to serve.

 

For most did not fight because they loved war.  They fought because their comrades were fighting.  They fought because they believed others needed protecting.  They fought because duty demanded it.

 

And in that willingness to place another person's wellbeing before their own, we catch sight of something profoundly human and, perhaps, something profoundly holy.

 

That is where today's reading from St Paul speaks so powerfully.  Writing to a grieving Christian community, Paul says: "We do not want you to be uninformed about those who sleep in death, so that you do not grieve like the rest of mankind, who have no hope."

 

Notice that Paul does not tell them not to grieve.  Christian faith has never required the suppression of grief.  The names carved into war memorials matter because the lives they represent mattered.  The tears shed by those left behind matter because love matters.

 

Paul is not speaking against grief.  He is speaking against despair.  There is all the difference in the world between those two things.

 

The Christian does not deny the reality of death.  We know its pain.  We know its cruelty.  We know the ache of separation.  What Christian faith insists upon, however, is that death is not the final reality.  Through the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ, God has declared that death will not have the last word.

 

The final word belongs to God.

 

At the heart of our faith stands one who surrendered his right to protect himself for the sake of others.  In Christ we see the deepest expression of self-giving love.  He refused to answer violence with violence.  He accepted suffering rather than inflict it.  He entrusted himself completely to the Father's purposes.

 

The sacrifices we remember today are not the same as Christ's sacrifice, but they can point towards it.  They are echoes of that same pattern of self-giving love that lies at the very heart of the Gospel.  And because God raised Jesus from the dead, we believe that such love is never ultimately wasted.

 

Not forgotten by God.Not rendered meaningless by history.Not lost.Not in vain.

 

Perhaps that is why the poppy has endured as our symbol of remembrance.

The poppy does not conceal the horror of war.  It grows from scarred ground and emerges from places marked by suffering and loss.  Year after year it returns, as though reminding us that memory is stronger than forgetting and that hope can sometimes emerge from the very places where hope seemed impossible.

 

The question, then, is not simply whether their sacrifice was in vain.  The question is what we shall do with the inheritance they have left us.

 

Will we work for peace?  Will we care for those who still carry the wounds of war?  Will we resist the forces of hatred, prejudice and division?  Will we strive to build the kind of society in which fewer young people are asked to make such sacrifices in the future?

Those are the questions remembrance places before us.

 

Peter concludes his poem with these words:

"So, poppy fields keep growing for us to wear,And wear your poppy with pride, for those who died there."

 

Today we remember the fallen.  We remember the living.  We remember the cost of war and the preciousness of peace.

 

And standing among the poppies, standing before the memorials, standing in the light of Christ's resurrection, we dare to answer that question which rises from every battlefield and every grave.

 

No, their sacrifice was not in vain.

 

For it still calls us to courage. It still calls us to gratitude. It still calls us to the difficult work of peace.  Above all, it points us towards the God whose love is stronger than death, whose mercy outlasts every conflict, and in whose kingdom the final word is not war, nor grief, nor loss, but life everlasting. 

 

Amen.

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page