Reflection on the readings for the 15th November, Safeguarding Sunday
Readings: Psalm 91; 1 Corinthians 13
Today’s reflection is by the Vicar, the Revd Canon Jonathan Cain.
Love Protects
When we hear Paul's words from 1 Corinthians, many of us hear them through the lens of a wedding. Many of us will have heard them standing beside a bride and groom. Some of us may have chosen them for our own wedding service. They have become so familiar that it might be easy to forget why Paul wrote them in the first place. The Apostle was not offering marriage advice. He was writing to a church. And not a particularly harmonious church at that.
The Christians in Corinth were energetic, gifted and enthusiastic. They possessed spiritual gifts in abundance. They were confident in their knowledge and proud of their faith. On the surface, they may even have looked successful. Yet beneath all that activity lay rivalries, divisions and struggles for status. People were measuring themselves against one another. Gifts that had been given for service had become opportunities for self-promotion. The community was losing sight of the very reason those gifts had been given in the first place.
It is into that situation that Paul writes some of the most challenging words in the New Testament:
"If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal."
"If I have prophetic powers."
"If I understand all mysteries and all knowledge."
"If I have faith that can move mountains."
Without love?
"I am nothing."
Notice what he does not say. He does not say that love is one virtue among many nor suggest that love is a welcome addition to an otherwise healthy church. Rather, he insists that love is the thing without which everything else loses its meaning. Prophecy, knowledge, generosity, faith itself; all these count for nothing if they are not rooted in love. That should give every church pause.
Because a church can have gifted leaders, flourishing activities, healthy finances and a good reputation. It can be busy every day of the week and appear successful by almost every measure we might think of. Yet if love is absent, Paul's judgement is uncompromising: "I am nothing."
On Safeguarding Sunday, that raises an important question. What does a church without love actually look like? Perhaps our minds immediately jump to headline-grabbing scandals, to dysfunctional organisations, to communities that are obviously unhealthy. Yet I suspect the reality is often more subtle than that.
Paul's concern in Corinth is not that people have stopped being friendly to one another. His concern is that ambition, status and self-interest have begun to distort the community's vision. When that happens, people start protecting positions rather than people. They become more concerned with appearances than with truth. Difficult questions are avoided and uncomfortable realities are pushed to the margins.
And where truth becomes difficult, secrecy begins to flourish. That is one of the dangers Paul is warning against.
Competitive and rivalrous communities rarely become more truthful. More often they become more secretive. People learn which things can be spoken about and which things cannot. They learn which conversations threaten reputations, which questions disturb the peace, and which realities are simply too awkward to confront. Truth becomes inconvenient. And whenever truth becomes inconvenient, vulnerable people are placed at risk.
Because abuse depends on secrets and flourishes in darkness. Abuse depends upon victims believing they will not be heard. It depends upon bystanders convincing themselves that somebody else will act. It depends upon communities deciding, consciously or unconsciously, that preserving comfort is more important than confronting painful realities. That is why I found myself returning this week to the story of Antonia Sobocki.
As a child Antonia Sobocki experienced abuse within her family, yet at the same time she found encouragement, friendship and support within her local church. The church was one of the places where she encountered hope and stability in the midst of pain.
Years later Antonia encountered reports of widespread abuse and cover-up within the Church. The institution that had once nurtured her faith suddenly appeared implicated in the very kind of suffering she herself had endured. The sense of betrayal was profound. Trust was shaken. A place that had once seemed safe no longer felt safe.
One phrase in her story has stayed with me. She spoke of discovering a "church-shaped hole" in her life. A church-shaped hole. There is something deeply moving about that phrase.
The Church is called to point people towards the love of God. It is called to be a place of refuge, healing and belonging. Yet when power is abused, and when abuse is hidden, the result is not merely organisational failure. What is left behind is a wound. A void where trust once existed. A church-shaped hole.
And that brings us back to Paul's description of love. For Paul, love is not principally a feeling, it is a way of being together. Love is patient and kind. It is not arrogant or self-seeking. It does not delight in evil but rejoices in the truth. And, significantly for today, love always protects.
Notice that Paul holds those two things together.
Love rejoices in the truth.
Love always protects.
Christian love never asks us to choose between protection and truth. Indeed, protection depends upon truth. The vulnerable are protected when people are willing to listen, willing to notice, willing to ask questions, willing to speak honestly when something does not seem right.
Now, at this point it would be easy to hear all this and think that Paul is describing somebody else's church. After all, the community gathered here today is not Corinth. One of the gifts of this congregation is precisely the quality of the relationships we share. This is a church where people know one another, care for one another and support one another. There is warmth here. There is kindness here. There are friendships that have endured for years.
And those things are not weaknesses. They are gifts from God. Yet every gift carries its own particular temptation.
In a close-knit community it can sometimes be harder, not easier, to ask difficult questions. We do not want to upset people. We do not want to think badly of someone we have known for years. We do not want to create conflict where relationships matter deeply. The stronger the relationships, the greater the temptation to assume everything is fine.
That is why safeguarding is not simply about responding to obvious dangers. It is about cultivating a culture in which truth and love belong together.
Because love without truth can become sentimentality. It can become a desire to keep everyone happy and lead to a reluctance to speak uncomfortable truths for fear of causing offence.
Yet truth without love becomes something else entirely: harshness, judgement and suspicion. Paul offers a better way.
The community he imagines is neither suspicious nor naïve. It neither rushes to condemn nor turns a blind eye. It is a community shaped by love and therefore committed to truth; a community confident enough in its relationships that difficult conversations can take place and honest concerns can be heard.
In many ways that commitment to truth lies at the heart of Antonia Sobocki's story. What eventually proved healing for her was not simply that people expressed sympathy. It was that people listened. Hidden experiences were spoken aloud. Silence was broken. Survivors discovered that they could tell the truth about what had happened and be heard. And perhaps that is one reason safeguarding belongs so naturally within the Christian faith.
Again and again in the Gospels, Jesus brings hidden things into the light. He listens to voices others would rather ignore. He notices those who have been pushed to the margins. He refuses both condemnation and denial. The people who encounter him are drawn into truth because truth is where healing begins.
That is also why safeguarding is about much more than policies, important though those are. It is about the kind of community we are becoming together. It is about whether those who come among us experience something of God's character in our common life.
And that means that our willing cooperation with safeguarding training, risk assessments, DBS checks and the other disciplines of safeguarding is itself an act of love. It says that the trust we share as a Christian community is not founded simply on friendship, familiarity or good intentions, but on our willingness to be accountable to one another. In that sense, safeguarding is not a burden imposed upon the Church but is one of the ways we learn to love one another well.
Throughout this service we have returned repeatedly to the image of God as refuge and shelter. The psalmist speaks of resting beneath God's wings. We have sung of God as our rock in times of trouble. We have prayed to the God who defends the weak, the weary and the oppressed. These are not simply comforting images. They tell us something about who God is.
The God revealed in scripture is the God who hears the cry of the vulnerable, who honours the truth, who exposes what is hidden and who offers refuge to those who are afraid. If that is who God is, then the Church that bears God's name must seek to embody those same qualities.
Not perfectly.
Not because we always get things right.
But because that is our calling.
I find the phrase "church-shaped hole" so powerful because it reminds us what is ultimately at stake. The Church exists to point beyond itself to the God whose nature is love. When that vocation is betrayed, people can be left carrying wounds for years. Yet when a church truly reflects the character of Christ, something very different becomes possible. Instead of a church-shaped hole, people discover a church-shaped shelter: a community where they are known, heard and valued; a community through which they glimpse something of God's faithfulness, God's truth and God's care.
"And now faith, hope and love abide, these three; and the greatest of these is love."
Love that rejoices in the truth.
Love that protects the vulnerable.
Love that refuses secrecy.
Love that is willing to ask difficult questions.
Love that creates safety.
To the God who is love,
who rejoices in the truth,
who shelters us beneath his wings,
and whose everlasting arms are our sure refuge;
be all honour and glory, thanksgiving and praise,
now and for ever.
Amen.

